Monticello School District
Sullivan County, New York
25 Single Homes offered from $300,000 to $500,000

Page 1 2 3
Photo of 31 West Thompson Place
$304,999
29
31 West Thompson Place
Smallwood
 
3 Beds, 1 Full Bath
61,855 sqft, 1.42 Acres
Age 66, Listed on Nov 19, 2024
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 11 Gale Road
$325,000
39
11 Gale Road
Mongaup Valley
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
27,025 sqft, 0.62 Acre, 2 Garage
Age 77, Listed on Mar 17, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 107 East Thompson Place
$325,000
29
107 East Thompson Place
Smallwood
 
3 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
44,867 sqft, 1.03 Acres
Age 86, Listed on Sep 11, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 48 Galia Road
$329,000
14
48 Galia Road
Bethel
 
3 Beds, 3 Full Bath
20,000 sqft, 0.46 Acre
Age 51, Listed on Sep 03, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 24 St Josephs Hill Road
$338,580
5
24 St Josephs Hill Road
Forestburgh
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
37,897 sqft, 0.87 Acre, 2 Garage
Age 76, Listed on Sep 03, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 41 West Delaware Place
$365,000
10
41 West Delaware Place
Smallwood
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
17,500 sqft, 0.4 Acre
Age 39, Listed on Mar 07, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 28 Lake Street
$375,000
2
28 Lake Street
Monticello
 
3 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
7,000 sqft, 0.16 Acre
Age 116, Listed on Mar 25, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 105 Wood Avenue
$375,000
9
105 Wood Avenue
Monticello
 
4 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
15,000 sqft, 0.34 Acre, 1 Garage
Age 86, Listed on Mar 21, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 20 Valley Road
$399,000
38
20 Valley Road
Forestburgh
 
4 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 2 Half Bath
59,242 sqft, 1.36 Acres
Age 38, Listed on Oct 20, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 110 Plank Road
$399,000
30
110 Plank Road
Mongaup Valley
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
230,868 sqft, 5.3 Acres, 2 Garage
Age 26, Listed on Mar 17, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 139 Haddock Road
$399,999
40
139 Haddock Road
Monticello
 
3 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
218,671 sqft, 5.02 Acres, 1 Garage
Age 37, Listed on Jul 08, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Page 1 2 3
Photo of 30 Straight Path
$425,000
23
30 Straight Path
Rock Hill
 
2 Beds, 2 Full Bath
7,500 sqft, 0.17 Acre
Age 40, Listed on Mar 31, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 36 Gina Lane
$439,500
36
36 Gina Lane
Bethel
 
3 Beds, 3 Full Bath
45,320 sqft, 1.04 Acres
Age 37, Listed on Aug 15, 2024
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 1 Decker Farm Road
$439,900
12
1 Decker Farm Road
Monticello
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
26,350 sqft, 0.6 Acre, 1 Garage
Age 19, Listed on Mar 11, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 128 Shore Drive
$449,900
50
128 Shore Drive
Wurtsboro
 
2 Beds, 1 Full Bath
14,810 sqft, 0.34 Acre
Age 15, Listed on Mar 17, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 37 Sycamore Trail
$450,000
41
37 Sycamore Trail
Wurtsboro
 
3 Beds, 3 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
33,977 sqft, 0.78 Acre
Age 28, Listed on Aug 04, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 144 Lucky Lake Drive
$450,000
5
144 Lucky Lake Drive
Rock Hill
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
47,916 sqft, 1.1 Acres
Age 37, Listed on Nov 26, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 36 Waverly Avenue 34
$450,000
1
36 Waverly Avenue 34
Monticello
 
3 Beds, 1 Full Bath
20,160 sqft, 0.46 Acre
Age 86, Listed on Mar 26, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 135 Lake Shore Drive
$465,000
44
135 Lake Shore Drive
Rock Hill
 
5 Beds, 2 Full Bath
13,504 sqft, 0.31 Acre
Age 54, Listed on Jan 20, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 196 Happy Avenue
$475,000
31
196 Happy Avenue
Swan Lake
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
546,678 sqft, 12.55 Acres
Age 22, Listed on Dec 10, 2024
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 2 Cardiff Lane
$479,000
22
2 Cardiff Lane
Rock Hill
 
4 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
12,197 sqft, 0.28 Acre, 2 Garage
Age 22, Listed on May 14, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 97 East Glen Wild Road
$489,000
36
97 East Glen Wild Road
Glen Wild
 
4 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
36,000 sqft, 0.83 Acre, 2 Garage
Age 57, Listed on Jul 07, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Page 1 2 3
Photo of 15 Manchester Road
$494,900
46
15 Manchester Road
Rock Hill
 
4 Beds, 3 Full Bath
12,629 sqft, 0.29 Acre, 2 Garage
No Age, Listed on Feb 13, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 13.-3-14.2 Rock Ridge Drive 2
$495,000
11
13.-3-14.2 Rock Ridge Drive 2
Monticello
 
3 Beds, 3 Full Bath
108,900 sqft, 2.5 Acres, 2 Garage
No Age, Listed on Mar 23, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 2757 State Route 42
$497,500
18
2757 State Route 42
Forestburgh
 
2 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
112,820 sqft, 2.59 Acres
Age 1, Listed on Nov 19, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info