Homes for Sale By School District

Monticello School District
Sullivan County, New York

35 Single Homes offered from $300,000 to $500,000

Page 1 2 3 4

$304,000

179 Heiden Road

Thompsonville

3 Beds, 2 Full Bath

43,996 sqft, 1.01 Acres, 2 Garage

Age 72, Listed on Jul 09, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$304,999

31 West Thompson Place

Smallwood

3 Beds, 1 Full Bath

61,855 sqft, 1.42 Acres

Age 65, Listed on Nov 19, 2024

$315,500

201,247 sqft, 4.62 Acres

Age 4, Listed on May 03, 2025

$319,900

16,117 sqft, 0.37 Acre, 1 Garage

Age 55, Listed on May 29, 2025

$325,000

7,405 sqft, 0.17 Acre

Age 65, Listed on Jul 31, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$325,000

107 East Thompson Place

Smallwood

3 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

44,867 sqft, 1.03 Acres

Age 85, Listed on Sep 11, 2025

$329,000

12,160 sqft, 0.28 Acre

Age 87, Listed on May 22, 2025

$345,000

3 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

29,910 sqft, 0.69 Acre, 2 Garage

Age 37, Listed on Sep 05, 2025

$349,000

5 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

8,232 sqft, 0.19 Acre, 1 Garage

Age 65, Listed on Sep 04, 2025

$349,000

4 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

6,300 sqft, 0.14 Acre, 1 Garage

Age 69, Listed on May 21, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$349,000

21 Rock Ridge Avenue

Monticello

3 Beds, 2 Full Bath

7,501 sqft, 0.17 Acre

Age 103, Listed on Feb 27, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

Page 1 2 3 4

$349,999

4 Ann Street

Monticello

5 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 2 Half Bath

6,100 sqft, 0.14 Acre

Age 125, Listed on Apr 25, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$350,000

24 St Josephs Hill Road

Forestburgh

3 Beds, 2 Full Bath

37,897 sqft, 0.87 Acre, 2 Garage

Age 75, Listed on Sep 03, 2025

$365,000

3 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

8,250 sqft, 0.19 Acre, 1 Garage

Age 65, Listed on Aug 21, 2025

$370,000

20,000 sqft, 0.46 Acre

Age 55, Listed on Jun 14, 2025

$375,000

3 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

218,671 sqft, 5.02 Acres, 1 Garage

Age 36, Listed on Jul 08, 2025

$379,000

20,000 sqft, 0.46 Acre

Age 50, Listed on Sep 03, 2025

$389,000

1,584 sqft, 0.04 Acre

Age 125, Listed on Apr 16, 2025

$390,900

6,534 sqft, 0.15 Acre

Age 65, Listed on Jul 02, 2025

$399,000

12,100 sqft, 0.28 Acre, 2 Garage

Age 21, Listed on Aug 01, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$399,000

10 Hanover Drive

Monticello

3 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

22,198 sqft, 0.51 Acre, 2 Garage

Age 57, Listed on Apr 17, 2025

$425,000

45,000 sqft, 1.03 Acres, 2 Garage

Age 61, Listed on Aug 31, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

Page 1 2 3 4

$429,999

31 Forestburgh Road

Monticello

3 Beds, 1 Full Bath

15,600 sqft, 0.36 Acre

Age 125, Listed on Jun 13, 2025

$439,500

45,320 sqft, 1.04 Acres

Age 36, Listed on Aug 15, 2024

$444,900

4 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

117,176 sqft, 2.69 Acres, 2 Garage

Age 60, Listed on Jul 28, 2025

$449,900

18,513 sqft, 0.43 Acre

Age 1, Listed on May 22, 2025

$450,000

3 Beds, 3 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

33,977 sqft, 0.78 Acre

Age 27, Listed on Aug 04, 2025

$475,000

546,678 sqft, 12.55 Acres

Age 21, Listed on Dec 10, 2024

$475,000

2 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

87,120 sqft, 2 Acres

Age 96, Listed on Aug 07, 2025

$479,000

4 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

12,197 sqft, 0.28 Acre, 2 Garage

Age 21, Listed on May 14, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$485,000

135 Lake Shore Drive

Rock Hill

5 Beds, 2 Full Bath

13,504 sqft, 0.31 Acre

Age 53, Listed on Jul 17, 2025

$489,000

4 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

2 Garage

Age 21, Listed on Apr 06, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$489,000

97 East Glen Wild Road

Glen Wild

4 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

36,000 sqft, 0.83 Acre, 2 Garage

Age 56, Listed on Jul 07, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

Page 1 2 3 4

$499,000

63 Pebble Path

Rock Hill

4 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

12,632 sqft, 0.29 Acre, 2 Garage

Age 53, Listed on Jun 23, 2025

$499,900

10,750 sqft, 0.25 Acre

Age 32, Listed on Jul 04, 2025

schedule a tour

request info