Homes for Sale By School District

$825,000

47

670 Creamery Road

Mongaup Valley

3 Beds, 2 Full Bath

1,998,533 sqft, 45.88 Acres, 3 Garage

Age 81, Listed on Jul 18, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$829,999

14

47 Washington Lane

Monticello

2 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

382,892 sqft, 8.79 Acres

Age 14, Listed on Oct 28, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$844,750

16

13 West Shore Road

Swan Lake

2 Beds, 2 Full Bath

8,091 sqft, 0.19 Acre

Age 34, Listed on Mar 01, 2026

schedule a tour

request info

$879,000

50

415 North Shore Drive

Wurtsboro

2 Beds, 2 Full Bath

52,272 sqft, 1.2 Acres

Age 22, Listed on Dec 08, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$990,000

43

111 Deer Meadow Road

Bethel

4 Beds, 3 Full Bath

226,512 sqft, 5.2 Acres

Age 35, Listed on Jul 28, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$999,999

50

2489 Ny-42

Forestburgh

4 Beds, 2 Full Bath

187,744 sqft, 4.31 Acres

Age 176, Listed on Nov 14, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$1,100,000

24

97 Pittaluga Drive

Monticello

5 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

467,399 sqft, 10.73 Acres, 4 Garage

Age 22, Listed on Mar 02, 2026

41,264 sqft, 0.95 Acre

Age 20, Listed on Mar 07, 2024

schedule a tour

request info

$1,250,000

28

24 Highland Drive

South Fallsburg

11 Beds, 7 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath

24,394 sqft, 0.56 Acre

Age 77, Listed on Jan 25, 2026

schedule a tour

request info

$1,499,999

50

1775 Plank Road

Forestburgh

4 Beds, 4 Full Bath

246,550 sqft, 5.66 Acres, 2 Garage

Age 35, Listed on Jun 07, 2025

schedule a tour

request info

$1,550,000

39

55 Chapin Trail

Bethel

4 Beds, 4 Full Bath

228,690 sqft, 5.25 Acres, 4 Garage

Age 6, Listed on Mar 05, 2026

schedule a tour

request info