Monticello School District
Sullivan County, New York
18 Single Homes offered from $500,000 to $800,000

Page 1 2
Photo of 188 Wolf Lake Road
$524,900
34
188 Wolf Lake Road
Rock Hill
 
2 Beds, 2 Full Bath
24,004 sqft, 0.55 Acre, 2 Garage
Age 65, Listed on Oct 23, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 253 Bowers Road
$539,000
41
253 Bowers Road
Rock Hill
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
229,561 sqft, 5.27 Acres, 4 Garage
Age 22, Listed on Apr 06, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 3 Old Westbrookville Road
$540,000
42
3 Old Westbrookville Road
Wurtsboro
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
2 Garage
Age 12, Listed on Sep 26, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 1528 Rt-17b
$550,000
32
1528 Rt-17b
White Lake
 
2 Beds, 2 Full Bath
9,953 sqft, 0.23 Acre
Age 13, Listed on Oct 29, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 541 Cold Spring Road
$575,000
38
541 Cold Spring Road
Monticello
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
85,813 sqft, 1.97 Acres, 1 Garage
Age 99, Listed on Oct 28, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 72 Black Lake Road
$599,000
22
72 Black Lake Road
Bethel
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
230,432 sqft, 5.29 Acres, 2 Garage
Age 37, Listed on Aug 21, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
google maps image
$619,900
465 County Route 56
Wurtsboro
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
96,268 sqft, 2.21 Acres
Age 10, Listed on Jul 23, 2024
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 99 West Starlight Drive
$625,000
36
99 West Starlight Drive
Smallwood
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
60,984 sqft, 1.4 Acres
Age 86, Listed on Jun 29, 2024
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 241 Royce Road 75
$649,000
43
241 Royce Road 75
Bethel
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
92,347 sqft, 2.12 Acres, 1 Garage
Age 58, Listed on Oct 20, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 12 Woodstone
$650,000
28
12 Woodstone
Bethel
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
270,072 sqft, 6.2 Acres
Age 12, Listed on Mar 07, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 413 Sackett Lake Road
$689,900
48
413 Sackett Lake Road
Monticello
 
4 Beds, 3 Full Bath
14,910 sqft, 0.34 Acre
Age 18, Listed on May 30, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Page 1 2
Photo of 3 Stone Path
$699,000
33
3 Stone Path
Rock Hill
 
3 Beds, 3 Full Bath
18,295 sqft, 0.42 Acre, 2 Garage
Age 55, Listed on Oct 17, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 209 Gregory Road
$699,900
23
209 Gregory Road
Monticello
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
Sqft Not Included
Age 9, Listed on Aug 18, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 224 Lake Shore Drive
$747,500
36
224 Lake Shore Drive
Monticello
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
2 Garage
Age 4, Listed on Jul 12, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 358 Horseshoe Lake Road
$769,000
50
358 Horseshoe Lake Road
Swan Lake
 
4 Beds, 3 Full Bath
73,616 sqft, 1.69 Acres, 1 Garage
Age 21, Listed on Sep 25, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 4159 West Shore Drive
$795,000
29
4159 West Shore Drive
Bethel
 
4 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
14,738 sqft, 0.34 Acre, 1 Garage
Age 60, Listed on Aug 15, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 380 Fraser Road
$799,000
24
380 Fraser Road
Kiamesha Lake
 
6 Beds, 3 Full Bath, 2 Half Bath
24,255 sqft, 0.56 Acre
Age 65, Listed on Mar 17, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 194 Canal Road
$799,900
44
194 Canal Road
Wurtsboro
 
4 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
19,720 sqft, 0.45 Acre, 2 Garage
Age 82, Listed on Jul 26, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info