Monticello School District
Sullivan County, New York
12 Single Homes offered from $800,000+

Page 1 2
Photo of 670 Creamery Road
$825,000
47
670 Creamery Road
Mongaup Valley
 
3 Beds, 2 Full Bath
1,998,533 sqft, 45.88 Acres, 3 Garage
Age 81, Listed on Jul 18, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 47 Washington Lane
$829,999
14
47 Washington Lane
Monticello
 
2 Beds, 1 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
382,892 sqft, 8.79 Acres
Age 14, Listed on Oct 28, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 13 West Shore Road
$844,750
16
13 West Shore Road
Swan Lake
 
2 Beds, 2 Full Bath
8,091 sqft, 0.19 Acre
Age 34, Listed on Mar 01, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 415 North Shore Drive
$879,000
50
415 North Shore Drive
Wurtsboro
 
2 Beds, 2 Full Bath
52,272 sqft, 1.2 Acres
Age 22, Listed on Dec 08, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 111 Deer Meadow Road
$990,000
43
111 Deer Meadow Road
Bethel
 
4 Beds, 3 Full Bath
226,512 sqft, 5.2 Acres
Age 35, Listed on Jul 28, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 2489 Ny-42
$999,999
50
2489 Ny-42
Forestburgh
 
4 Beds, 2 Full Bath
187,744 sqft, 4.31 Acres
Age 176, Listed on Nov 14, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 97 Pittaluga Drive
$1,100,000
24
97 Pittaluga Drive
Monticello
 
5 Beds, 2 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
467,399 sqft, 10.73 Acres, 4 Garage
Age 22, Listed on Mar 02, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 3443 Nys Hwy 55
$1,197,500
0
3443 Nys Hwy 55
Bethel
 
8 Beds, 4 Full Bath
41,264 sqft, 0.95 Acre
Age 20, Listed on Mar 07, 2024
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 24 Highland Drive
$1,250,000
28
24 Highland Drive
South Fallsburg
 
11 Beds, 7 Full Bath, 1 Half Bath
24,394 sqft, 0.56 Acre
Age 77, Listed on Jan 25, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 58 Deer Meadow Road
$1,360,000
50
58 Deer Meadow Road
White Lake
 
4 Beds, 3 Full Bath
252,648 sqft, 5.8 Acres, 2 Garage
Age 11, Listed on Apr 02, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info
Photo of 1775 Plank Road
$1,499,999
50
1775 Plank Road
Forestburgh
 
4 Beds, 4 Full Bath
246,550 sqft, 5.66 Acres, 2 Garage
Age 35, Listed on Jun 07, 2025
schedule a tour
 
request info
Page 1 2
Photo of 55 Chapin Trail
$1,550,000
39
55 Chapin Trail
Bethel
 
4 Beds, 4 Full Bath
228,690 sqft, 5.25 Acres, 4 Garage
Age 6, Listed on Mar 05, 2026
schedule a tour
 
request info